Marketing Best Practice

Demystifying Email Security Bots and Kulea's Approach to Addressing Them

By Andrew Nicholson · Published 1 August 2023 · 5 min read

In the realm of email marketing, a rapidly evolving landscape marked by ever-changing algorithms and consumer behaviours, email security bots have emerged as both a boon and a bane.

In this article, we'll look at what email security bots are, what they do, their effect on email open and click rates, and why addressing them is crucial - and how Kulea has proactively taken steps to identify and neutralise bot activity for the benefit of our users.

Key findings

  • Email security bots automatically scan messages for threats, but their scanning activity registers as opens and clicks - inflating metrics with no real human engagement.
  • Gmail's image pre-fetching and Apple's Mail Privacy Protection have sharply increased false-open activity in recent years.
  • Kulea identifies bots via IP address and user-agent analysis, flags suspicious events, and automatically excludes them from campaign reports and automation triggers.
  • This means your reported open/click rates will look lower than a platform that doesn't filter bots - but the numbers will actually be true.

What Are Email Security Bots and What Do They Do?

Email security bots - often referred to as email scanners, or less politely, "those damned bots" - are automated tools designed to analyse email content, attachments, and links to identify potential security threats such as phishing attempts, malware, or spam. These bots act as a layer of protection to ensure users receive safe and secure emails. While essential for maintaining email security, their scanning activity can inadvertently affect email marketing metrics.

How Email Security Bots Influence Open and Click Rates

When an email is sent, security bots automatically scan its content and links, registering opens and clicks in the process. This leads to inflated open and click rates, making it difficult for email marketers to accurately gauge real engagement - distorting analytics, misrepresenting campaign performance, and skewing decision-making.

Not Malicious, Just Inconvenient

It's worth noting that email security bots aren't malicious entities deliberately trying to distort your metrics. They serve a genuinely important purpose in safeguarding users against security threats. Their automated actions just happen to inadvertently skew performance metrics along the way - which is frustrating, but not sinister.

The Rise of Bot Activity: Gmail Pre-fetch and Apple's Mail Privacy Protection

In recent years, the prevalence of email security bot activity has surged, largely thanks to advancements in email platforms like Gmail's image pre-fetching and Apple's Mail Privacy Protection. These features proactively load and cache images in emails to enhance user experience and privacy - inadvertently registering false opens along the way. This has posed a real challenge for email marketers, requiring adaptations to accurately interpret engagement metrics.

Identifying Bots: IP Addresses and User Agents

Email security bots can be identified and isolated through analysis of IP addresses and user agents. IP addresses associated with bot activity often display unusual patterns - high-frequency visits, or a lack of other typical interactions. Examining user agents can also reveal inconsistencies in device or browser type, providing further clues to distinguish bots from genuine engagement.

Kulea's Proactive Approach to Combating Bot Activity

At Kulea, we understand the importance of mitigating the impact of email security bots on your campaigns. Here's what we've built to identify and neutralise bot activity:

  • Enhanced data exports and API integration: IP addresses and user agents are now included in our behaviour exports and API, so you can efficiently identify suspicious bot-related activity yourself.
  • Flagging suspicious events and a bot toggle: Within a contact's event timeline, we flag suspicious events and give you the ability to filter them out with an intuitive bot toggle.
  • Upgraded bot filtering: Our filtering mechanisms detect bot activity based on specific behaviours, including concurrent open and click events, multiple clicks within a short timeframe, and engagement with predefined "bot bait" links.

Any events we identify using these filters are automatically excluded from your campaign reports and automated journey triggers. This will result in lower headline open and click-through rates - but we believe it's always better to be open about bot activity than to quietly fudge the numbers.

Continual Vigilance: Weekly Reviews and Filter Updates

To stay ahead of evolving bot strategies, we review activity on a weekly basis. Our team assesses new IP and user agent pairings, keeping our bot filters updated and effective at identifying and neutralising new bot patterns as they emerge.

Your Input Matters

We appreciate our customers' vigilance, and encourage you to report any unidentified bots to your account manager. Your proactive involvement helps us swiftly address and include new bot patterns in our ongoing updates. Bot-busting will always be a work in progress as new bots are released and new IP/user-agent pairings emerge, but we're working hard behind the scenes to stay on top of it.

Final Thoughts

Email security bots play a genuinely important role in protecting users from threats - but their influence on email marketing metrics can't be ignored. At Kulea, we remain committed to staying ahead of these developments, continuously adapting our tools to keep your engagement data accurate and trustworthy.

Should you have any questions about email security bots, or our approach to addressing them, get in touch - we're here to help at every step of your email marketing journey.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are email security bots?

Email security bots are automated tools that scan email content, attachments, and links to detect phishing, malware, or spam. Their scanning activity registers as opens and clicks, inflating email marketing metrics even though no human actually engaged.

How does Kulea filter out bot activity from email metrics?

Kulea flags suspicious events based on behaviours like concurrent open-and-click events, multiple clicks within a short timeframe, and engagement with predefined bot-bait links. Flagged events are automatically excluded from campaign reports and automation triggers.

Andrew Nicholson

Andrew Nicholson

Co-founder & CEO at Kulea. Guest lecturer in digital psychology and behavioural economics at the University of Buckingham.

Want engagement data you can actually trust?

Book a demo